Cases Pending Before The Supreme Court

NOTE: Cases are added to this table when they are taken up by the Court. Note that oral argument dates may change at any time. After oral arguments, a link to the archived video recording is added. Cases are removed when the mandate issues (or, for attorney disciplinary matters, approximately 30 days after the opinion was filed).

Click on the column title to sort by that column.



Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 2456, Sept. Term, 2024 (unreported)

Case No.YearPetitionerRespondentCert. GrantedOral ArgumentsOpinion FiledIssues
021
2026State Board of ElectionsHowell 2026-09-03
[Oral Arguments]
2026-09-03
[PC Order]
Direct appeal under Maryland Election Law.
022
2026State Board of ElectionsWheatley 2026-09-03
[Oral Arguments]
2026-09-03
[PC Order]
Direct appeal under Maryland Election Law.
005
2026HammondState2026-05-222026-09-04
[Oral Arguments]
2026-10-26
[Opinion]
Criminal Procedure – 1) As a matter of first impression, can forgetting to register for the Maryland sex offender registry serve as a defense to a charge of “knowingly” failing to register under Criminal Procedure Article § 11-721(a) and, if so, under what circumstances? 2) Did the trial court err in convicting Petitioner of knowingly failing to register after finding as a fact that Petitioner forgot to register?

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 615, Sept. Term, 2024 [Opinion]
024
2026RussellState Board of Elections 2026-09-04
[Oral Arguments]
2026-09-04
[PC Order]
Direct appeal under Maryland Election Law.
061ag
2025Reinstatement of Thomas-Bellamy to the Bar  2026-09-08
[Oral Arguments]
 In the Matter of the Petition for Reinstatement of Sandy F. Thomas-Bellamy to the Bar of Maryland
011ag
2025Attorney Grievance Comm'nConlon 2026-09-08
[Oral Arguments]
 Attorney disciplinary matter.
001
2026Lakeview Loan Serv.Baxter2026-02-202026-09-08
[Oral Arguments]
 Commercial Law – 1) Does the definition of “credit grantor” contained in Maryland’s Closed End Credit Provisions (CLECs) (§§ 12-1001 to 1030 of the Commercial Law Article) encompass mortgage loan servicers like Petitioners, or is it limited to owners of the loan (including any subsequent assignees who purchased the loan)? 2) Given the CLEC’s carveout for fees associated with first-priority residential mortgage loans, did the telephone convenience fees that Petitioner charged Respondent violate the statute?

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 691, Sept. Term, 2024 [Opinion]
003
2026Unnamed AttorneyAttorney Grievance Comm'n2026-04-242026-09-08
[Oral Arguments]
 Court Rules - 1) Is the circuit court's order denying the motion to quash Bar Counsel's subpoena appealable? 2) Did the circuit court err in denying the motion to quash the subpoena?

No. C-24-CV-25-003532, Circuit Court for Baltimore City.
017ag
2025Attorney Grievance Comm'nSaleh 2026-09-09
[Oral Arguments]
2026-09-11
[PC Order]
Attorney disciplinary matter.
041
2025Meek-FreemanState 2026-09-09
[Oral Arguments]
 DNA appeal.

 
025
2026SweatPrince George's Cnty. Board of Elections 2026-09-09
[Oral Arguments]
 
2026-09-09
[PC Order]
Direct appeal under Maryland Election Law.
002
2026WilsonState2026-03-092026-10-01
[Oral Arguments]

The oral arguments in this matter were held at Guilford Park High School in Jessup, Maryland.
 Criminal Law – 1) When a criminal defendant presents evidence that he acted under an honest but mistaken belief of facts which, if true, would negate the mental state elements required for murder, may a trial court refuse a requested mistake-of-fact instruction on the ground that the concept is “fairly covered” by general instructions on perfect and imperfect self-defense? (from the petition for writ of certiorari). 2) Did ACM err because the mistake-of-fact jury instructions, as applied in this case, was not supported by “some evidence” to generate the instruction and because, even if the instruction were generated, it would not be error not to give it if it was fairly covered by the self-defense instruction? (from the cross-petition).

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 2293, Sept. Term, 2023 (unreported)
004
2026GaskillLewis2026-05-222026-10-01
[Oral Arguments]

The oral arguments in this matter were held at Guilford Park High School in Jessup, Maryland.
 Torts – 1) Whether this Court should overrule Southern Management Corp. v. Taha, 378 Md. 461 (2003) and adopt the same standard in civil and criminal cases as set forth in the concurring opinion in Price v. State, 405 Md. 10 (2008) and in Givens v. State, 449 Md. 433 (2016) for determining whether an allegedly inconsistent verdict is preserved for appellate review. 2) Whether the Appellate Court of Maryland erred in holding that the jury’s verdict was irreconcilably inconsistent under the Maryland Tort Claims Act and that the circuit court abused its discretion in approving the verdict sheet that allowed that inconsistent verdict. 3) Whether the Appellate Court of Maryland erred in holding that the jury instruction regarding one’s right to disagree with a police officer based on Diehl v. State, 294 Md. 466 (1982) is an incorrect statement of law and is not applicable to this case challenging unlawful police conduct.

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 2057, Sept. Term, 2023 (unreported)
012 AG
2025Attorney Grievance Comm'nBishop 2026-10-02
[Oral Arguments]
 Attorney disciplinary matter.
007
2026AndersonState2026-06-182026-10-02
[Oral Arguments]
 Criminal Law – 1) Did defense counsel’s objection preserve an exception to testimony that Baltimore City police have a “truth-telling” policy? 2) As a matter of first impression, does Spain v. State, 386 Md. 145 (2005), allow a detective to bolster police witness credibility by telling jurors there is a “departmental policy” requiring police to tell the truth, and that detectives are “subject to termination” if they lie?

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 1999, Sept. Term, 2023 (unreported)
009
2026CrowderState2026-06-182026-10-02
[Oral Arguments]
 Criminal Law – 1) Does the ACM’s holding in Logan v. State, 164 Md. App. 1 (2006), control whether the trial court must conduct voir dire on whether the venire has strong feelings on an anticipated defense or does the SCM’s later decision affirming Logan control? 2) When the only issue in a murder trial is the viability of a defense, must a court, on request, probe the venire’s bias against that defense? 3) In voir dire, are defenses ever a mandated area of inquiry? 4) Did the trial court err in refusing to ask the venire about strong feelings on deadly force in self-defense or defense of others?

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 1565, Sept. Term, 2023 (unreported)
027
2026RhodaState Board of Elections 2026-10-02
[Oral Arguments]
2026-10-07
[PC Order]
Direct appeal under Maryland Election Law.
002jd
2025In the Matter of Hon. Gipson  2026-10-05
[Oral Arguments]
2026-10-05
[PC Order]
Judicial disabilities matter.
008
2026ElliottState2026-06-182026-10-05
[Oral Arguments]
 Criminal Law – 1) For purposes of determining whether a prospective juror should be excused for cause, does a rebuttable presumption of bias arise where the juror discloses during voir dire that she was the victim of a crime very similar to the crime charged in the case on trial? 2) Where Petitioner was charged with assaulting his wife and mother-in-law with a firearm, did the trial court abuse its discretion in refusing to excuse for cause a prospective juror who was the victim of a very similar act of domestic violence in a case then pending before the same trial judge? 3) Did ACM err in holding that Petitioner failed to preserve the argument that the trial court insufficiently questioned the prospective juror?

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 1091, Sept. Term, 2024 (unreported)
010
2026Corenic Const. Grp.Single Point Const.2026-06-182026-10-05
[Oral Arguments]
2026-10-14
[PC Order]
Contracts – 1) Did ACM improperly interpret unambiguous contract terms to relieve Respondent of obligations it assented to, but subsequently changed its mind about or regretted? 2) Did ACM exceed its authority by sua sponte vacating a decision of the trial court that was not raised by either party on appeal or in its appeal briefing?

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 2284, Sept. Term, 2023 (unreported)
017
2026GarlitzState2026-7-172026-11-02
[Oral Arguments]
 Criminal Law – Can a reasonable probability of tampering be negated in order to authenticate evidence pursuant to Maryland Rule 5-901 where a controlled purchase involves a confidential informant, who is subsequently unavailable to testify and whose transaction cannot be corroborated by police?

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 368, Sept. Term, 2024 (unreported)
014 AG
2025Attorney Grievance Comm'nBoykin 2026-11-04
[Oral Arguments]
 Attorney disciplinary matter.
014
2026Harford Cnty.Penman2026-7-172026-11-04
[Oral Arguments]
2026-11-10
[PC Order]
Local Government – Is Respondent, a sheriff’s deputy, disqualified by Charter § 207 from simultaneously holding office as a County Councilmember and a deputy because Respondent’s employment as a deputy is employment by the government of the State of Maryland?

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 2182, Sept. Term, 2024 (unreported)
011
2026StateJ.C.2026-06-232026-11-09
[Oral Arguments]
 Torts – Where the Child Victims Act of 2023 expands only the “time for filing” a child sex abuse claim, does sovereign immunity continue to bar any such claim against the State that arose prior to July 1, 1982, the effective date of the Maryland Tort Claims Act’s limited sovereign immunity waiver? 

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 75, Sept. Term, 2026 (pending)
015
2026StateSmith2026-7-172026-11-09
[Oral Arguments]
 Criminal Procedure – 1) Under New York v. Hill, 528 U.S. 110 (2000), does defense counsel’s active participation in selecting a trial date outside the Interstate Agreement on Detainers’ 180-day period constitute a waiver of the statutory time limits? 2) Does the IAD require an open-court good cause finding or verbatim contemporaneous recording of a scheduling discussion as a prerequisite to finding waiver, even when the State proffers and the defense concedes that the parties and court jointly selected a trial date beyond the 180-day period?

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 1736, Sept. Term, 2024 [Opinion]
026 AG
2024Attorney Grievance Comm'nOwens 2026-12-03 Attorney disciplinary matter.
012
2026DellClarke2026-07-172023-12-03 Real Property – Does a party to a foreclosure action who elects not to pursue a permitted interlocutory appeal from an order denying a motion to stay a foreclosure sale forfeit appellate review of that order on a later appeal from the final judgment ratifying the sale?

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 1862, Sept. Term, 2024 (unreported)
016
2026JacobsenPorter2026-7-172026-12-03 Corporations & Associations – From the petition: Whether, consistent with Rule 8-131(a), an appellate court can order a remand based on a legal theory that was not raised, argued or preserved in the trial court. From the cross-petition: 1) Do managing members of an LLC owe a duty of candor to another managing member when convening a board meeting to vote on that member’s removal? 2) Is a managing member harmed when co-managers deceive him about the purpose of a removal meeting, depriving him of the ability to prepare a defense or protect his ownership interest? 3) Does the entire-fairness standard apply to conflicted transactions by managing members of an LLC absent an express provision in the operating agreement, and if so, was it satisfied here? 4) Did the lower courts misapply the doctrine of unclean hands as a basis for denying equitable relief?

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 2290, Sept. Term, 2023 (unreported)
013
2026CheungHoward Hughes Med. Institute2026-7-172026-12-07 Civil Procedure – Was it an abuse of discretion under Rule 2-341, directing that “[a]mendments shall be freely allowed when justice so permits,” to deny leave to reassert previously dismissed counts when discovery revealed new evidence supporting those counts?

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 2290, Sept. Term, 2023 (unreported)
018
2026Sinai Hospital of Balt.Caples2026-08-202026-12-07 Courts & Judicial Proceedings – Did the Appellate Court erroneously apply Courts & Judicial Proceedings § 5-609?

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 1527, Sept. Term, 2024 [Opinion]
019
2026StateMurray2026-08-202026-12-07 Criminal Law – 1) Where evidence, such as a social media message, is subject to competing inferences, is that evidence irrelevant as a matter of law, as ACM found, or is that evidence subject to the usual balancing of probative value versus unfair prejudice under Maryland Rule 5-403? 2) Is a trial court’s determination of relevance under Maryland Rule 5-401 reviewed de novo, for abuse of discretion, or under a bifurcated approach? 3) Did the trial court properly admit Respondent’s social media message? 

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 701, Sept. Term, 2024 (unreported)
001 Misc.
2026A.G.N. Amer. Div. of Seventh Day Adventists 2027-01-04 Certified question of law from the United States District Court for the District of Maryland

Assuming that Maryland's statute of limitations laws must be applied to the instant tort claims, does the Maryland Child Victims Act of 2023, Md. Code Ann., CJP § 5-117, apply to claims of sexual abuse by a plaintiff, where that plaintiff suffered the abuse as a minor, where that plaintiff is not currently and was not at the time the abuse occurred a Maryland resident, where the abuse occurred outside of Maryland, and where the defendants are Maryland entities who are alleged to be principals of the perpetrators of the abuse?
032
2026BerhanuState2026-09-242027-01-04 Criminal Law – 1) Does testimony that a non-testifying forensic analyst “verified” the testifying analyst’s testing of the evidence in the case convey the substance of the absent analysts out-of-court statement for purposes of the Confrontation Clause of the Sixth Amendment and Article 21 of the Maryland Declaration of Rights? 2) May the State, consistent with the Confrontation Clause, introduce testimony that a non-testifying analyst verified the testifying analyst’s results on the ground that it rebuts doubt created by the defendant’s cross examination? 3) If the testimony was admitted in violation of the Confrontation Clause, did the Appellate Court misapply the harmless-error standard by concluding that any error was harmless because the jury could have inferred, from the testimony describing the laboratory’s requirement that all conclusions be verified, that the requirement was followed in Petitioner’s case?

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 1449, Sept. Term, 2024 (unreported)
020
2026LeoneLeone2026-08-202027-01-07 Maryland Rules – 1) When a trial judge has heard testimony from all witnesses and admitted evidence during a trial, but recuses themself before issuing a final judgment, does the subsequent judge have the discretion to issue a final judgment on all remaining issues if they have carefully reviewed the evidence admitted as well as the transcript and audio recording of all testimony? 2) Did ACM err by relying on jurisprudence from sister states which have adopted a federal rule that is not analogous to Md. Rule 2-536? 3) Did ACM err in vacating those portions of the trial court’s order that were supported by uncontested facts, such as the issuance of the judgment of divorce itself? 4) Should ACM have required the initial judge’s basis for recusal to be put on the record, when Respondent acknowledged that a party who causes a recusal cannot then seek a mistrial?

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 1476, Sept. Term, 2025 (unreported)
033
2026Marlow Hts. Shopping Ctr.Macy's Retail2026-09-242027-01-07 Real Property – 1) Did the Appellate Court commit reversible error by holding that a 1959 deed that does not, on its face, purport to convey the easement sought by Appellees “can be understood … to effect the conveyance” of the easement because it incorporates generally, by reference a 1958 Memorandum of Understanding (the “MOA”), which also does not purport, on its face, to convey an easement? 2) Did the Appellate Court commit reversible error by relying on an equitable maxim (“equity treats that as done which ought to be done”) that has never been used for this purpose to treat the 1959 Deed incorporating the promise to convey a perpetual easement in the memorandum as having conveyed the easement? 3) Did the Appellate Court commit reversible error by affirming the Circuit Court’s rulings that this action was not time-barred?

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 2147, Sept. Term, 2024 (unreported)
029
2026ZlotnitskyZlotnitsky2026-09-242027-01-08 Family Law – Does Maryland’s doctrine of dissipation apply where one spouse transfers funds from a joint marital stock account to another joint marital stock account, where the funds first gained in value but later declined, and where there was no evidence that any funds were spent, concealed, diverted for a non-marital purpose, or used for that spouse’s personal benefit? 

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 2512, Sept. Term, 2024 (unreported)
030
2026HunterState2026-09-242027-01-08 Criminal Law – Did the suppression court correctly deny Appellant’s motion to suppress, where police stopped Appellant because they had reasonable suspicion that he was carrying a gun in his pocket?

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 883, Sept. Term, 2025 (pending)
028
2026VolpeHough2026-09-24  Local Government – 1) Did the Appellate Court improperly find that the proposed usage “substantially impaired the integrity” of the general plan or the master plan as set forth in Prince George’s County Code 27-213(a)(3)? 2) Was the District Council and Zoning Hearing Examiner’s opinion supported by “substantial evidence”?

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 593, Sept. Term, 2023 (unreported)
031
2026WardState2026-09-24  Criminal Law – From the petition for writ of certiorari: 1) When an appellant shows that a trial court abused its discretion by striking a prospective juror for insufficient cause, must the appellant also prove that the jury ultimately empaneled was not fair and impartial before obtaining appellate relief, or is reversal required upon a showing of either a clear abuse of discretion on the part of the trial judge or prejudice to the appellant? 2) Did the Appellate Court err in denying Petitioner any appellate relief where, after holding that the trial court abused its discretion in striking that juror, the Court concluded that appellate relief was unavailable because there was “no basis on which to conclude that the members of the jury who served were unfair or partial or that the fairness and impartiality of the jury as a whole was compromised by the court’s decision”? From the conditional cross-petition for writ of certiorari: Did the trial court properly exercise its discretion in striking a prospective juror for cause where the juror’s responses to voir dire did not persuade the court that the juror would base his decision solely on the evidence at trial?

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 1569, Sept. Term, 2024 (unreported)
035
2026GebrehawariatDibba2026-10-23  Courts & Judicial Proceedings – 1) Did the Appellate Court err in extending the patient-therapist privilege under Courts & Judicial Proceedings Article §9-109 to communications made during a child-forensic interview, where the psychologist was retained by counsel solely to conduct a forensic assessment rather than to provide diagnosis or treatment?

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 2456, Sept. Term, 2024 (unreported)
036
2026State, et al.Cunningham2026-10-23  Torts – Did ACM err in determining that the Maryland Tort Claims Act’s three-year deadline for bringing suit is subject to minority tolling, where complying with that deadline is a condition precedent to the State’s waiver of sovereign immunity?

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 216, Sept. Term, 2025 [Opinion]
037
2026Pro-Football, Inc.Brooks2026-10-23  Workers’ Compensation – 1) Is an employee “regularly employed” in Maryland under Labor & Employment Article § 9-203(a)(2) based solely upon an employment contract contemplating possible future work in Maryland when any future Maryland work depended upon the employee first surviving a competitive roster-reduction process? 2) Did ACM depart from Pro-Football, Inc. v. McCants, 428 Md. 270 (2012), and Pro-Football, Inc. v. Tupa, 197 Md.App. 463 (2011), by replacing their fact-dependent inquiry into the regularity of an employee’s Maryland employment with a categorical “ongoing employment relationship” test satisfied by the mere existence of an employment contract? 

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 549, Sept. Term, 2025 [Opinion]
038
2026ASAP Roofing & ExteriorsMyers Mgmt.2026-10-23  Civil Procedure – 1) Whether the Court of Special Appeals’ (now known as the Appellate Court of Maryland) decision in Abrishamian v. Washington Medical Group, P.C., 216 Md.App. 386, 408, 86 A.3d 681 (2014) which broadly permits disqualification of counsel alleged to be a necessary witness a) without a hearing and b) “to any aspect of the litigation the circuit court deems appropriate” should be reconsidered by this court. 2) Whether disqualification of a party’s chosen counsel in a civil case requires sworn testimony and an evidentiary hearing when facts are contested and which party bears the burden of proof. 3) Whether the circuit court applied the proper standing in refusing to award Petitioner attorneys’ fees regarding the disqualification dispute given that Petitioner was awarded all of the relief it sought; Petitioner had the contractual right to recover all of its “costs of collection;” and all of Petitioner’s claims were based on a common core of facts.

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 2456, Sept. Term, 2024 (unreported)
039
2026CoreLife Mgmt. ServicesCalvert Health Sys.2026-10-23  Civil Procedure – 1) Did ACM err in holding that CoreLife failed to preserve for appellate review its challenges to the default judgment? 2) Did ACM err in holding that the circuit court properly entered a default judgment against CoreLife and dismissed CoreLife’s counterclaims under Rule 2-613 as a sanction for noncompliance with a scheduling order? 3) Did ACM err in upholding the circuit court’s damages award?

Appellate Court of Maryland, No. 821, Sept. Term, 2025 (unreported)