Argument Schedule -- January, 2027

SCHEDULE OF ORAL ARGUMENTS

September Term, 2026

 

Monday, January 4, 2027:

Bar Admissions

Misc. No. 1 A.G., et al. v. North American Division of Seventh-Day Adventists, et al.

Certified question of law from the U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland

Assuming that Maryland's statute of limitations laws must be applied to the instant tort claims, does the Maryland Child Victims Act of 2023, Md. Code Ann., CJP § 5-117, apply to claims of sexual abuse by a plaintiff, where that plaintiff suffered the abuse as a minor, where that plaintiff is not currently and was not at the time the abuse occurred a Maryland resident, where the abuse occurred outside of Maryland, and where the defendants are Maryland entities who are alleged to be principals of the perpetrators of the abuse?

No. 32 Kaleab Abebe Berhanu v. State of Maryland

Issues – Criminal Law – 1) Does testimony that a non-testifying forensic analyst “verified” the testifying analyst’s testing of the evidence in the case convey the substance of the absent analysts out-of-court statement for purposes of the Confrontation Clause of the Sixth Amendment and Article 21 of the Maryland Declaration of Rights? 2) May the State, consistent with the Confrontation Clause, introduce testimony that a non-testifying analyst verified the testifying analyst’s results on the ground that it rebuts doubt created by the defendant’s cross examination? 3) If the testimony was admitted in violation of the Confrontation Clause, did the Appellate Court misapply the harmless-error standard by concluding that any error was harmless because the jury could have inferred, from the testimony describing the laboratory’s requirement that all conclusions be verified, that the requirement was followed in Petitioner’s case?

 

Thursday, January 7, 2027:

No. 20 Stacey Leone v. David Christopher Leone

Issues – Maryland Rules – 1) When a trial judge has heard testimony from all witnesses and admitted evidence during a trial, but recuses themself before issuing a final judgment, does the subsequent judge have the discretion to issue a final judgment on all remaining issues if they have carefully reviewed the evidence admitted as well as the transcript and audio recording of all testimony? 2) Did ACM err by relying on jurisprudence from sister states which have adopted a federal rule that is not analogous to Md. Rule 2-536? 3) Did ACM err in vacating those portions of the trial court’s order that were supported by uncontested facts, such as the issuance of the judgment of divorce itself? 4) Should ACM have required the initial judge’s basis for recusal to be put on the record, when Respondent acknowledged that a party who causes a recusal cannot then seek a mistrial?

No. 33 Marlow Heights Shopping Center Limited Partnership v. Macy's Retail Holdings, LLC, et al.

Issues – Real Property – 1) Did the Appellate Court commit reversible error by holding that a 1959 deed that does not, on its face, purport to convey the easement sought by Appellees “can be understood … to effect the conveyance” of the easement because it incorporates generally, by reference a 1958 Memorandum of Understanding (the “MOA”), which also does not purport, on its face, to convey an easement? 2) Did the Appellate Court commit reversible error by relying on an equitable maxim (“equity treats that as done which ought to be done”) that has never been used for this purpose to treat the 1959 Deed incorporating the promise to convey a perpetual easement in the memorandum as having conveyed the easement? 3) Did the Appellate Court commit reversible error by affirming the Circuit Court’s rulings that this action was not time-barred?

 

Friday, January 8, 2027:

No. 29 Chanan Zlotnitsky v. Limor Zlotnitsky

Issue – Family Law – Does Maryland’s doctrine of dissipation apply where one spouse transfers funds from a joint marital stock account to another joint marital stock account, where the funds first gained in value but later declined, and where there was no evidence that any funds were spent, concealed, diverted for a non-marital purpose, or used for that spouse’s personal benefit?

No. 30 Stephen Hunter v. State of Maryland

Issue – Criminal Law – Did the suppression court correctly deny Appellant’s motion to suppress, where police stopped Appellant because they had reasonable suspicion that he was carrying a gun in his pocket?

 

After January 8, 2027, the Court will recess until February 4, 2027. 

On the day of argument, counsel must register in the Clerk’s Office no later than 8:30 a.m. unless otherwise notified.

 

GREGORY HILTON
CLERK