SCHEDULE OF ORAL ARGUMENTS
September Term, 2026
Thursday, December 3, 2026:
Bar Admissions
AG No. 26 (2024 T.) Attorney Grievance Commission v. Joseph Michael Owens
Justice Getty will sit in place of Justice Killough.
Attorney for Petitioner: Courtenous Q. Herbert, Jr.
Attorney for Respondent: William C. Brennan
No. 12 Mary Lou Dell v. James E. Clarke, et al.
Issue – Real Property – Does a party to a foreclosure action who elects not to pursue a permitted interlocutory appeal from an order denying a motion to stay a foreclosure sale forfeit appellate review of that order on a later appeal from the final judgment ratifying the sale?
Attorneys for Petitioner: Evan V. Goitein and Clifford J. Boan
Attorneys for Respondent: John Ansell, III and Scott B. Wheat
No. 16 Jeffrey Jacobson, et al. v. Henry Porter, et al.
Issues – Corporations & Associations – From the petition: Whether, consistent with Rule 8-131(a), an appellate court can order a remand based on a legal theory that was not raised, argued or preserved in the trial court. From the cross-petition: 1) Do managing members of an LLC owe a duty of candor to another managing member when convening a board meeting to vote on that member’s removal? 2) Is a managing member harmed when co-managers deceive him about the purpose of a removal meeting, depriving him of the ability to prepare a defense or protect his ownership interest? 3) Does the entire-fairness standard apply to conflicted transactions by managing members of an LLC absent an express provision in the operating agreement, and if so, was it satisfied here? 4) Did the lower courts misapply the doctrine of unclean hands as a basis for denying equitable relief?
Attorneys for Petitioner/Cross-Respondent: Margaret M. McKee and James H. West
Attorney for Respondent/Cross-Petitioner: William N. Sinclair
Monday, December 7, 2026:
No. 13 Vivian Cheung v. Howard Hughes Medical Institute
Issue – Civil Procedure – Was it an abuse of discretion under Rule 2-341, directing that “[a]mendments shall be freely allowed when justice so permits,” to deny leave to reassert previously dismissed counts when discovery revealed new evidence supporting those counts?
Attorney for Petitioner: Steven M. Klepper
Attorney for Respondent: Catherine E. Stetson
No. 18 Sinai Hospital of Baltimore, Inc., et al. v. Jacob Caples, et al.
Issue – Courts & Judicial Proceedings – Did the Appellate Court erroneously apply Courts & Judicial Proceedings § 5-609?
Attorney for Petitioner: M. Peggy Chu
Attorney for Respondent: Kevin Sullivan
No. 19 State of Maryland v. Devron Ny'Quez Murray
Issues – Criminal Law – 1) Where evidence, such as a social media message, is subject to competing inferences, is that evidence irrelevant as a matter of law, as ACM found, or is that evidence subject to the usual balancing of probative value versus unfair prejudice under Maryland Rule 5-403? 2) Is a trial court’s determination of relevance under Maryland Rule 5-401 reviewed de novo, for abuse of discretion, or under a bifurcated approach? 3) Did the trial court properly admit Respondent’s social media message?
Attorney for Petitioner: James N. Lewis
Attorney for Respondent: Nancy S. Forster
After December 7, 2026, the Court will recess until January 4, 2027.
On the day of argument, counsel must register in the Clerk’s Office no later than 8:30 a.m. unless otherwise notified.
GREGORY HILTON
CLERK
